Translate This Blog

Tuesday, July 7, 2015

Pros And Cons Of Invisible/Electric Fences....And A Contest!

From time to time I am asked by clients about my opinion on using a wireless dog fence (sometimes called "invisible" or electronic fences) for dogs.  And yes, I have thoughts on the issue!  Also.....I have a contest!  But I'll get to that at the end.

The short version is that I do think that an electronic dog fence is a very viable option for many people.  I know from personal experience that having a physical fence is expensive and can be difficult to install if you try to do it yourself.  My own yard doesn't have a fence and we've been considering having one put in for a long time.  Last year we finally decide to do so and got a few quotes.  The cheapest one was around $2600, and they went up from there.  That cost wasn't really in our budget and as a second choice I looked into invisible fencing.

An invisible fence was a much more reasonable option.  I looked at a few companies who did the full installation as well as a DIY electric fence.  I finally decided on the latter because for less than $300 I could get a full kit plus an extra collar.  I will admit that it was a bit of work putting it in, as I had to measure and arrange the wire, set up the transmitter, dig small trenches in which to bury the wire, and make sure the whole thing worked.  It took several hours last Summer, and while not back-breaking it was a bit tedious.  In the end I got it installed and within a couple of weeks had my dogs trained.

The fence has worked great for a year and is still going strong.  My dogs have learned the boundaries and don't approach them.  They are used to the collars and don't mind them.  In fact it has worked so well that we aren't planning on putting up a physical fence any time in the near future.

It's obvious that I'm biased in favor of these fences, but I'm still realistic about the occasional challenges.  Here are a few key points.
  • The collars provide a small static charge, not a full blast of electricity.  Yes, it's uncomfortable, but the collars make a tone as the dog approaches the wire, warning them in plenty of time.  My dogs learned very quickly where that line was, and don't go too close.  If fitted and used properly it doesn't cause any physical damage and the dogs learn when to stop so they don't actually receive the shock.  I can't remember the last time my dogs have actually received any kind of "punishment" from the collars.
  • This is a much cheaper alternative to a physical fence, which makes it a great option for people on a budget.  That was one of the main reasons I decided to use one.
  • If the electricity for your house goes out for some reason (storm, blown fuse, etc.) your fence is effectively down.  So don't let your dogs outside unsupervised if this is the case or they will not hear the tone of the collar and may go beyond the boundary.
  • If the battery in the collar dies you lose the benefit of the fence.  The collar won't give a tone or a shock if the dog approaches the boundary wire.  However, many dogs are so well trained by that point that they will stop at that border anyway.  And at least the brand I use will give a warning flash as the battery is losing power.
  • Thought it would happen rarely, there is a risk of a big, strong dog getting excited and taking a running start at the boundary line, breaking through it in about a second.  I've heard of this happening, and once the dog is through the other side the collar stops giving any signal since it relates to the proximity of the transmission wire.  This has never been an issue with my dogs and they both weigh around 60 pounds.  Be aware of your dog's personality and tendencies.
Wireless dog fences aren't for every dog, but they are definitely a good option for many.  Certainly look at it as an option if you don't need a physical fence for any reason other than to contain your dogs.  There are many types of invisible fence out there, so look around.  Here is one site for invisible fence reviews.

Okay, now the contest!    I want to see how many people are aware of this blog and willing to share it!  In order to "enter", you must either comment on this post or share it on social media (Facebook, Twitter, Google+, etc.).  Once you have done so send me an email at with either the link to where you shared it or your name/alias in the comments.  Doing both (commenting and sharing) will get you two entries!  I will need a valid email address in order to send the prize.  I will draw a person from random from those emails and that person will win a $25 electronic gift card!  Entries will be taken through Midnight (12:00am) EDT on Tuesday, July 14th, 2015.


  1. I have enjoyed reading and learning from your blog for quite a while, now. Please keep it up! :)

  2. I love your blog and have referred to you twice for assistance with my dogs. Your advice was really helpful and got us thru some tough adjustments when adding a new, big dog to my little dog home. You are right about needing to keep in mind the personality of your dog when considering an electric fence. We had a beagle, Copper, who was the sweetest little gal, but when she got wind of something interesting she took off like a jet! The electric fence never made her slow down for a second. Same with our pit cross, Sadie. She normally has no problem staying within the boundaries of the electric fence, but when she sees a deer in the woods across the way she just bolts thru the e-fence without blinking. They are both wonderful dogs, very mellow tempered..but single minded when it comes to chasing. I finally put up a wood fence to keep Sadie in.
    Thanks for your blog, it is great!

  3. I read your blogs(which you probably know haha) and greatly enjoy them. Not a boring piece is published and I just love when you add pictures of cases you do or just random pics(your super hero was awesome). I want to be a veterinarian for large animals(horses and cows mainly). Your works are very encouraging to read. I read a recent article that said anyone who wants to study to be a large animal vet should apprentice under a farrier first, as that helps with learning the equine anatomy. Do you agree with that? I think I'll do that too. Anyways, I'm rambling now. Keep writing and don't stop!!

  4. I am so glad that I found your blog. Your advice has been very helpful for our puppy.

  5. I love your blog. I'm a fairly new reader, stumbled on it recently when I was searching for something else pet-related, and have been reading ever since. (Went back and read old posts too.) THANK YOU for sharing your thoughts and expertise with us. It's like a peek "behind the curtain"!

  6. Thank you so much for all of the insight you have given into being a veterinarian. I have been following your blog for a long time now and I love relax on my Sundays and taking the time to read your new posts. I enjoy reading a variety of opinions on most subjects and I enjoy that I get to add yours to the list.

  7. I have been reading for a long time, not sure how or when I found the blog but I check it every day regardless, looking for a new entry. I love to see your thoughts on vet stuff (I work in anesthesia at a veterinary teaching hospital) but I also enjoy reading about your cosplay and your kids.

  8. Googled a question and your blog came up as having an answer. I plan to bookmark your blog. I know I have a lot to learn. Thanks

  9. I posted about your blog on Facebook but then lost the post, guess the news moved too quickly for me so I don't have a link for you. Thanks again!

  10. Well I very much enjoy your blog and will certainly shared on face book and link to Google plus

  11. Thanks to everyone for commenting! Even if you aren't winning something I always love hearing from the readers. The winner of the Amazon gift card has been chosen and they have been contacted via email. Congrats, Shirley!

  12. Thank you very much!! As I said before, I enjoy your blog and hope you're able to keep it going for a good while longer. It's good to read your stories/perspectives.

  13. Just found your blog and am really enjoying it. I sent my get practice a card thanking them after reading how hard it really is. I have three aussies, and consider myself a good dog mom. I love my vets and will be sure to let them know!


Thank you for making a comment on my blog! Please be aware that due to spammers putting links in their comments I moderate every comment. ANY COMMENTS WITH AN EXTERNAL LINK NOT RELATED TO THE TOPIC WILL LIKELY BE DELETED AND MARKED AS SPAM. If you are someone who is posting links to increase the traffic to another website, save me and you the time and hassle and simply don't comment. To everyone else.....comment away! I really do enjoy hearing from readers!