Translate This Blog

Thursday, October 8, 2009

"Dr. Layperson"

I was chatting on an online veterinary site recently, and several people were comparing notes about various crazy client complaints. One of the big things that comes up is clients who think they know better than the doctor, or somehow think that medicine is easy. Just this week I had a client bring in her shih-tzu puppy who was having diarrhea and vomiting. I had my tech present a treatment plan which included checking for intestinal worms, parvo, and giardia. The client asked her why I couldn't tell what was wrong with her dog. Umm....that's why I want to run the find out what's wrong...Apparently the person thought that I could figure out the problem simply with an exam, even though I had explained the possibilities to her before I stepped out of the room.

A few years ago I had a person (not a regular client) come into the office wanting to purchase Hill's K/D. This is a veterinary-only diet designed for pets in kidney failure. Because of its low protein levels (which are beneficial with renal disease) it's not recommended for pets with normal kidney function. Therefore we don't let anyone just walk in and pick up one of these diets without a good reason or authorization from another vet. He said that his dog had kidney disease and therefore he wanted the diet. I asked him why he thought this and if another vet had diagnosed kidney disease. He said no, he hadn't been to another vet and he knew the dog had kidney problems because it was urinating a lot. I explained that kidney disease couldn't be diagnosed without blood and urine tests and that there were several other problems that would cause an increase in urination (diabetes, urinary tract infections, Cushing's disease, etc.). He began to argue with me that he just knew his dog had problems with its kidneys and insisted on the food. I refused without any tests being run. He started yelling at me and became irate. I still didn't let him have the food, and he stormed out. Somehow his opinion based on a single symptom was better than my years of training, knowledge, and experience.

Believe it or not, that's not uncommon. I have had many people take the advice of breeders, store clerks, and friends over that of a veterinarian. These laypeople seemingly have greater skills and knowledge than a licensed and experienced doctor, or so certain clients appear to believe. There is an awful lot of "Doctor Layperson" syndrome out there, and it's frustrating to real doctors. I'm the first to admit that I don't know everything, and that there are other doctors who are smarter and better than me. But I sure as heck know more about immunology and vaccinations than a breeder and know more about flea life cycles and nutrition than the guy stocking at PetCo. In the end, I think it comes down to people believing what they want to believe. And to these people a medical degree means nothing if I'm not telling them the "right" things.

Thankfully these people are in the minority, though it is a larger minority than I like to see.


  1. If nothing else you reminded me that diabetes is not the only reason for drinking or urinating more. He's quit it now so it wasn't anything but I am a hypochondriac pet mama.

  2. Sorry, I haven't read this post, much as I want to. I find it really hard to read with the new colours, the white letters on a pale background are just too difficult.

    Shame, as I had been enjoying reading your blog. :(

  3. Hmmm. The background is a medium brown, and shouldn't be showing up as pale. Anybody else having problems reading the current color scheme?

  4. I just changed the font color, so hopefully it will be easier to read now.

  5. My favorite story like this is a man with a Goldendoodle who had chronic, nasty ear infections. He should have been partway through a food trial of z/d when he came back with another ear infection, saying that he stopped feeding it when his small bag ran out because "the breeder said there is no reason to be on it, as he is a hybrid and can't have allergies."


  6. Amen to that. Those people are so annoying. It's like why are you wasting my time and your money to come in here and not listen. Just recently I had to convince someone that puppy vaccines would not kill their new pup because the breeder told them it would. And they have been clients a long time!

  7. I'll fully admit that all medical professionals know more than I do. It's the "trust me, I'm a doctor" that annoys me. Dr. Bern has said he welcomes and will answer questions, but I've had some human doctors roll their eyes when I ask what the drug they are asking me to take is, let alone why they think I need it.


Thank you for making a comment on my blog! Please be aware that due to spammers putting links in their comments I moderate every comment. ANY COMMENTS WITH AN EXTERNAL LINK NOT RELATED TO THE TOPIC WILL LIKELY BE DELETED AND MARKED AS SPAM. If you are someone who is posting links to increase the traffic to another website, save me and you the time and hassle and simply don't comment. To everyone else.....comment away! I really do enjoy hearing from readers!