Translate This Blog

Sunday, July 27, 2014

Does Trap-Neuter-Release Help Feral Cat Populations?

TNR programs (Trap-Neuter-Release) are common in many Western countries as a way to control feral cat populations.  The idea is that when there is a community of wild, unowned domesticated cats we can help reduce and eliminate this population by capturing them, testing for certain diseases, vaccinating, spaying and neutering them, then returning them to the wild.  Advocates of this policy believe that simply capturing and euthanizing these cats provides a vaccuum in the population which allows new cats to enter and continue the process.  They also believe that this is the most human method of handling feral cats.  But does this really work?
 
Unfortunately a growing number of studies is casting considerable doubt on the efficacy of such programs.  The stated goals of reducing the number of feral cats is rarely reduced unless there is considerable effort made.  In fact, studies have shown that in these cases populations tend to remain stable rather than decreasing.  The more that researchers have looked at the issue, the less support there is for the idea that TNR programs reduce feral populations.
 
Yet you'll find that most humane societies, animal control departments, and rescue groups support this idea, and even promote the position that it really does work.  If you simply look at the logic of procedure it really should work since you're removing breeding cats from a population yet keeping them there to compete for resources.  Unfortunately the reality of the situation doesn't tend to support this, and many of the studies quoted by such groups really don't provide data as the grops think they do.
 
Does that mean that TNR shouldn't be done?  Honestly, I'm on the fence about it.  You'd be hard-pressed to find anywhere in the world where an average TNR program has eliminated a population of feral cats.  By this evidence it really is a waste of money.  At the same time, we must be affecting populations by spaying and neutering, and hopefully reducing cats with FIV or feline leukemia by testing for and euthanizing those who are positive.  Maybe it's my heart rather than my mind that wants to believe in continuing them.  I still wonder if there are better ways to spend limited resources.
 
For more information here are a few links.  Read through them, compare the data, and make your conclusions.
 
 

1 comment:

  1. I think it works, but I think it takes time and you have to keep at it. I'll use my aunt's farm as an example. When they bought the place it came complete with about 15 feral cats. They started seeking out the litters and made sure to socialize, vaccinate and alter all of them before placing most in other homes. They also trapped several of the feral adults and had them altered, further reducing the number of litters born on the farm. It took a while, partly because more cats kept showing up or getting dumped, but within about 10-12 years they were down to two altered cats that live in the barn. They pretty much built a wing on their very clinic over the years, but they did manage to control the population and eliminate the feral cat pack. It's been over twenty years now and they still just keep a couple of cats in the barn for mousing purposes -- and they still alter and place any new cats that show up. It's a Never ending cycle.

    My local shelter euthanizes all feral cats after a seven day stray hold. I wish some sort of TNR or farm adoption program was an option.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for making a comment on my blog! Please be aware that due to spammers putting links in their comments I moderate every comment. ANY COMMENTS WITH AN EXTERNAL LINK NOT RELATED TO THE TOPIC WILL LIKELY BE DELETED AND MARKED AS SPAM. If you are someone who is posting links to increase the traffic to another website, save me and you the time and hassle and simply don't comment. To everyone else.....comment away! I really do enjoy hearing from readers!